Not pictured: Willett |
--Single Cask Nation's MGP 8 year old Rye, barrel #52
--Smooth Ambler Old Scout 7 year old Rye, barrel #849 for K&L
--Redemption 7 year old Barrel Proof Rye, batch 6
--Willett 6 year old Family Estate Single Barrel Rye, barrel #122
With this being Kristen's birthday week I elected to review this string of MGP barrel proof rye. Why? Because my wife and I both enjoy the stuff. And I'm not sure if I can say that about many (or any) other whiskies. Before I did my four tastings, Kristen tried them (via small pours mind you, because damn) all side by side and ranked them by preference. Here are her notes:
Kristen's notes:
Single Cask Nation's MGP 8 year old Rye, barrel #52 -- "Smells a little industrial, or am I influenced by the sample label's typeface? Unremarkable overall." RANK: 4
Smooth Ambler Old Scout 7 year old Rye, barrel #849 for K&L -- "Burns longer on the tongue. Cinnabon, is that you?" RANK: 2
Redemption 7 year old Barrel Proof Rye, batch 6 -- "Burns longer in the back of the throat. A little hotter than I'd like." RANK: 3
Willett 6 year old Family Estate Single Barrel Rye, barrel #122 -- "Least hot. Smoothest. Smell is vegetal. Cilantro?" RANK: 1
"On my birthday I'll drink champagne! :)"
Yes you will, my dear.
So since she's always right, how did I fare? Here's a summary of my reviews. For the full reports click the links. And because I'm silly, I gave these whiskies scores. Anyway...
Michael's notes:
Single Cask Nation's MGP 8 year old Rye, barrel #52 -- "...very hot and difficult at full strength. In fact, I didn't want to drink anymore of it while doing this tasting."; "...soooooper woody"; "...adding water...cleaned [it] up reasonably well."
Score: 80, though much lower without added water. -- RANK: 4
Smooth Ambler Old Scout 7 year old Rye, barrel #849 for K&L -- "I wouldn't say this Old Scout is very complex, nor markedly better than the former regular 7yo release, but it's reliable as heck. Could set your watch to it, as the old saying goes."
Score: 87 -- RANK: 2
Redemption 7 year old Barrel Proof Rye, batch 6 -- "This isn't as much of an immediate hit as the Old Scout, but it's close."; "...a little young and rough at times, thus less 'smooth'"; "...the nose is great and the palate is perfectly acceptable, but I do wish there was more going on in the finish. "
Score: 85 -- RANK: 3
Willett 6 year old Family Estate Single Barrel Rye, barrel #122 -- "...in a different league than the other three ryes this week"; "...most exotic nose I've ever experienced on a rye"; "The palate...takes on different personalities...remains totally in balance throughout. The finish brings in new characteristics and flexes plenty of stamina."
Score: 90 -- RANK: 1
On her birthday, I'll drink champagne. But then it's back to whisky
Well, we agreed. Which is good. So, if you won't take my whiskey word for it, listen to the lady. We've both always loved our Willett ryes, but we've also really enjoyed the Old Scout stuff (including the bourbon single barrels). On such things historic eternal relationships are based. Happy Birthday, Kristen!
No comments:
Post a Comment