...where distraction is the main attraction.

Whisky Notes

There are two ways to view the 100-point grading system.

Comparable letter grades:
(updated 6/4/17)

96 to 100 - A+ : The stuff that dreams are made of.
93 to 95 - : Truly thrilling.  Can make one ponder his or her existence.
90 to 92 - A- : Excellent. If the style suits your palate, then I highly recommend this drink.
87 to 89 - B+ : Grand stuff, if I don't already own it then it's because the money tree croaked
84 to 86 - B : Very good whisky. It makes me smile when I see it on the shelf at a retailer or bar.
80 to 83 - B- : Solid, reliable whisky. Not without its flaws, but the positives out weigh 'em.
77 to 79 - C+ : Average. Pending the price, something I'd still order at a bar.
74 to 76 - C : Drinkable, but mildly disappointing as the bad starts to outweigh the good.
70 to 73 - C- : Not terrible, may be just for specific palates. I'd rather drink beer.
67 to 69 - D+ : Difficult to recommended. Either it's too sleepy or it's among the least of its type.
64 to 66 - D : Not recommended.
60 to 63 - D- : Considerably broken whisky.  Should avoid making eye contact.
00 to 59 - F : Failure from top to bottom.

Or, more simplified:

90 - 100 - Dynamite.  A lovely drink and something I would hope to possess for myself.
80 - 89 - Desirable.  Always reliable and I'll gladly pay you Tuesday for this whisky today.
70 - 79 - Drinkable.  I wouldn't turn it down, but I personally wouldn't pay for it.
60 - 69 - Dumpable.  Mediocre or worse.  Truly not recommendable to anyone.
00 - 59 - Disgusting.  Need I say more?

Click here for the ongoing Big Whisk(e)y List

The above grades are based on aesthetics only and thus issued independently of the whisky's price.  I don't feel comfortable listing a price-quality ratio/grade because the damn drink keeps getting more expensive every week.  But fear not!  I'll bitch about discuss pricing issues in almost every post anyway, usually right above where I list the score.


Sources for whisky information:
Jackson, Michael, et al. Michael Jackson's Complete Guide to Single Malt Scotch: A Connoisseur's Guide to the Single Malt Whiskies of Scotland. 6th Edition. New York, NY: DK Publishing, 2010.
Murray, Jim. Whisky Bible, 2012 Edition. Northhamptonshire, UK: Dram Good Books, 2011.
MacLean, Charles. Whiskypedia. A Compendium of Scotch Whisky. New York, NY: Skyhorse Publishing, 2010.
MacLean, Charles. Scotch Whisky, A Liquid History. London, UK: Cassell Illustrated, 2005.
Ronde, Ingvar (Ed.). Malt Whisky Yearbook 2012. Shropshire, UK: MagDig Media. 2011.
Roskrow, Dominic (Ed.). 1001 Whiskies You Must Taste Before You Die. New York, NY: Universe Publishing. 2012.

And...
individual distiller/bottler websites
winesearcher.com
whiskyfun.com
www.maltmaniacs.org/monitor.html
www.maltmadness.com/whisky/
My own senses

No comments:

Post a Comment