Here they are in order of sampling:
Kavalan - 40% ABV - $85-$105 ex-VAT w/shipping from Europe
Lots and lots of caramel in the nose and mouth. Hot cereal, like cream of wheat or oatmeal, on the nose. Buttered bread and dried grass in the palate. Brief finish. Very mild overall. An easy drinker, but also nearly characterless without the caramel.
Kavalan Concertmaster (Port finish) - 40% ABV - $85-$105 ex-VAT w/shipping from Europe
The port is very reserved, shows up mostly on the nose. Candy sweet on the palate with molasses and orange peel. Some of that orange note appears in the nose as well. Bitter cough syrup on the finish. It's a sweetie, might be good for cocktails?
55.6% ABV - $145-$195 ex-VAT w/shipping from Europe
Both very spirity and lots of charred American oak. Sugar cookies on the nose, along with some baking spices. Vanilla and ethyl on the palate, going from sweet to bitter and back again. A surprisingly quiet finish with a little bit of malt character. A couple guys at my end of the tasting table REALLY did not like this one.
Kavalan Solist vinho barrique - W071210025, bottle 53/197 - about 5 years old
57.7% ABV - $135-$160 ex-VAT w/shipping from Europe
(Per Master of Malt, the vinho barrique casks were fashioned from American oak and then seasoned with both wine and red wines.)
Very gentle considering the ABV. Raisins and other dried fruits on the nose. Brown sugar and burnt berries on the palate. More flavor and finish than the previous three. The wine seemed to overwhelm the whisky but I didn't mind so much, for a change.
Kavalan Solist Sherry Cask - S060710017, bottle 192/545 - about 6 years old
58.6% ABV - $160-$195 ex-VAT w/shipping from Europe
Dark chocolate and cinnamon candy in the nose. Lots of chocolate on the palate, sometimes with cherries, sometimes with figs. Soft bitterness and more of the cinnamon candy. A floral finish, with a little more chocolate in the background. The cinnamon candy notes reminded me of rye new make which made me wonder if this whisky was still too young or if the note came from the cask. While the chocolate notes were nice, they can't hold a candle to the chocolates in GlenDronach's single casks.
Kavalan Solist Fino - S060814011, bottle 467/529 - about 6 years old
58.6% ABV - $295-$320 ex-VAT w/shipping from Europe
From a big 'ol Fino butt. While it doesn't hold up to water well, it does just fine on its own. Toffee, caramel, and flower blossoms on the nose. A little tart and spirity on the palate, but still held the toffee and flowers nicely. Most substantial finish of the bunch.
The fact that a Taiwanese distillery is bottling a single malt IS a great thing. I'm all for supporting distillery growth around the world, even if many of those distilleries are mimicking the Scottish approach to whisky. That "approach" ain't bad, so I'm not complaining. It is also impressive that when following said approach, an international distillery makes a totally palatable product (see: Amrut, Three Ships, Mackmyra, or any Japanese distillery). Under the supervision of Jim Swan (who also consulted on Kilchoman's malt), the Taipei distillers have made a very Scotchy single malt.
I also like the fact that Kavalan is playing around with different kinds of casks. The fact that Kavalan bottles quite a number of single casks is great too. AND AND AND some of these whiskies will end up for sale at US retailers, probably next year.
Good stuff, right? And the writers who have lavished praise on Kavalan's malt are much more experienced than I. And while these writers are paid for their opinions, I do not think they are in the tank for Kavalan. I just think the excitement is a little much for very young whisky that goes for very large prices.
Very young whisky isn't necessarily bad whisky. Wonders have been worked at Kilchoman (again, props to Jim Swan) whose 4, 5, and 6 year old whisky can compete favorably with much older malt coming from its famous neighbors. The Springbank folks are also making some fine young stuff at Glengyle via their Kilkerran brand. And I personally like a little bark and bite in my whisky, before years of active oak tames the dog.
Add into all of this the potential for batch variation......
My god, how many disclaimers must I list before writing the following?
I was underwhelmed by the entire Kavalan lineup. And I have good reason to believe that at our tasting, I was amongst the majority in that opinion. My fellow drinkers were a mix of newbies, anoraks, and professionals, each with their own past experiences and preferences. A few folks liked the basic single malt as a guilty pleasure. A couple folks liked the sherry cask, though the Fino seemed to gather the most votes. But I didn't see or hear anyone get WOWed by any of these. Which is okay.
While I am not rating these six whiskies, I lean closer to the grades (or a step lower) given them by Whiskyfun and LAWS as opposed to those given by Whisky Advocate or the Whisky Bible. The two 40% ABV whiskies were inoffensive and would fit into the NAS starter malt market. The bourbon cask was educational, allowing me to find out what a 4 year old whisky tastes like at cask strength. The final three weren't half bad with the Fino probably ranking the highest. But subtract the hype and the brand -- how about a blind taste test! :) -- and I'm not sure how well these stack up on the whisky market at large.
And then the prices. Take another look at those prices, which will probably remain similar when Kavalan comes to The States. What you're paying for is not necessarily the whisky. You're paying for a very pretty distillery in the Republic of China. You're paying for processes and ingredients that are more expensive in Taipei than in Rothes or Louisville. You're paying for taxes and tariffs. You're paying for the unique experience of drinking Taiwanese whisky.
But think of all the other great whiskies you could be buying at those prices...